Article 18 of the European Union

“No EU citizen can be treated differently due to his nationality or place of residence. No citizen can be placed at a disadvantage as a result of these two circumstances”
Article 18 of the EU treaty specifically outlaws any kind of discrimination on the basis of nationality, while this definition was extended to include also “place of residence” by the CJEU (The Court of Justice of the European Union).
But, notwithstanding the specific legal obligations cited, does this really work out? It might do so in a broad sense of the word but it seems that it does not work out when it comes to Malta !
Two recent situations, over the past few weeks, have shown that the above becomes merely fiction where Malta is concerned as in both cases both Malta as a country and its residents have been placed at a severe disadvantage by rules enacted by the European Union itself.
The first, and surely the most damaging for our island economy, is the stricter application of ETS. A carbon tax that will be applied to all maritime and air transportation within EU countries, with a view of further expansion towards countries outside the Union. Should a shipment of food be moving between say Germany and Italy, the shipment would normally be moved by land transport: be it road or train. The same would apply for persons moving between the two countries where they may use alternative transport to air by utilising cars or trains. No such choices are available in the case of Malta: any merchandise (including such basic necessities as food) can only move between Malta and other EU countries utilising merchant ships or ferries with no alternatives possible.
The same applies to people travelling between Malta and other EU countries where the choice lies between air transport and ferries with no other alternatives.
The cost for these operations for the Maltese economy is going to be heavy. It is calculated that the ETS cost for airline operations, at present rates, will top €88 million per year, while the cost for the moving a container will come close to €1000 per container. It is obvious that these costs cannot be absorbed by the industry or by government and, wholly or partially, will have to be passed on the consumer: meaning US!
The second circumstance that has, very lately, cropped up is the question of EU emergency funds for incidents such as the damages brought about by Storm Harry. The cost of the heavy damages caused by the storm can, theoretically, be partially covered by special EU emergency funds. Well it works out that this is not so because a quirky rule that covers these funds stipulates that the full amount available can only be dished out to regions and not countries so that Sicily (hit by the same storm but classed as a region) will have access to funds to which Malta is not entitled! So, by definition, small countries like Malta, San Marino, Luxemburg or Lichtenstein can never be helped in an emergency even if such funds are available from the Union!
The two circumstances listed above are certainly a double-whammy for Malta and seriously puts in doubt the full validity of Article 18 both legally and in spirit.
Should we expect more surprises in the future just for being a small island state?
Author: Ray Bugeja