Malta’s Chief Justice has called on Parliament to set aside political divisions and revive stalled constitutional reforms, warning that without unity, critical progress in the justice sector may remain incomplete

At the official opening of the Forensic Year on 1 October 2025, Chief Justice Mark Chetcuti delivered a measured yet unmistakable reminder of the challenges facing Malta’s justice system, expressing regret that Parliament failed to reach consensus on crucial constitutional reforms.

The Chief Justice noted that while government proposals aimed to strengthen judicial competencies, reduce delays, and introduce a Commissioner for Judicial Standards, these required a two-thirds majority in Parliament. Only one measure, which required a simple majority, was approved. “Two constitutional amendments, relevant exclusively to the judiciary and the justice sector, did not receive the full commitment of Parliament as expected and desired,” he observed.

Without naming political parties, Chetcuti made it clear that the lack of cross-party support was deeply disappointing. He emphasised that these reforms were not partisan in nature but “rooted in the practical needs of the judiciary and the public interest.” His words, though carefully chosen, conveyed frustration that judicial reforms had become entangled in political divisions.

“I am not, in any way, giving an opinion or passing judgment on what happened, but I must express my personal regret,” the Chief Justice said, urging Parliament to revisit the issue in a spirit of consensus.

Despite this criticism, Chetcuti acknowledged the significant progress achieved in recent years. He pointed to the creation of a Magisterial Inquiries Section, which has reduced delays in pending inquiries, and the expansion of the Civil and Commercial Court of Appeal, which has cut waiting times from years to months. Additional reforms, including legislation establishing a specialised Commercial Court, have also been implemented.

Infrastructure improvements, such as a new Valletta building for magisterial inquiries and plans to centralise specialised courts, further reflect the justice system’s ongoing modernisation. The Chief Justice credited the judiciary for these achievements while acknowledging constructive cooperation with the government, marked by what he described as mutual respect for constitutional roles.

European institutions, including the Venice Commission, have recognised this collaborative model. Yet Chetcuti’s address served as a reminder that meaningful reform requires unity across Parliament. Without broad support, he warned, key improvements risk remaining unfinished.