EU court AG backs Malta on ‘Citizen by Investiment’ scheme

Malta’s controversial ‘Citizen by Investment’ scheme, allowing foreigners to purchase EU citizenship in exchange for investing upwards of €690,000, could be offered a legal reprieve following an opinion produced for the EU’s top court on Friday.
Granting citizenship is a power EU member states kept for themselves, said the non-binding report by Advocate General Anthony Collins, brushing aside European Commission concerns of undermining the EU’s integrity.
“Member States have decided that it is for each of them alone to determine who is entitled to be one of their nationals and, as a consequence, who is an EU citizen,” said a statement from the Court of Justice.
“There is no logical basis for the contention that because Member States are obliged to recognise nationality granted by other Member States, their nationality laws must contain any particular rule,” the statement added.
Judges at the Court of Justice will decide on the case in the near future; they aren’t obliged to follow Advocate General opinions, though in the majority of cases they do.
The European Commission took the legal action years ago, arguing that the ‘Citizen by Investment’ scheme breached Malta’s duty to cooperate sincerely.
ECJ annuls obligation for transport vehicles to return to Malta every 8 weeks
The European Court of Justice has annulled the obligation for transport operators to return their vehicles to the member state in which they are registered.
The decision was welcomed by Malta’s Ministry for Transport, Infrastructure, and Public Works and the governing Labour Party.
The effect for Malta will be that the ECJ annulled the EU obligation in Regulation 2020/1055 for truck trailers on the continent to return to Malta every eight weeks.
Malta, Lithuania, Bulgaria, Romania, Cyprus, Hungary, Malta, and Poland brought actions for annulment before the Court of Justice against the Mobility Package, adopted by the European Parliament and the Council, in 2020.
The court dismissed all the actions brought forward by the states, except in so far as they are directed against the obligation relating to the return of vehicles, which the court annulled.
Ruling against Meta over Facebook targeting ads
Social media platforms must restrict the use of personal data for targeted advertising, to comply with the bloc’s regulatory law, the EU Court of Justice ruled on Friday.
The ruling comes as a blow to social media giant Meta, which collects digital data of users of its social media platform Facebook when they visit other websites and use third-party apps, which allows Meta to personalise advertising.
But under the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation, companies are obliged to adhere to the principle of “data minimisation”, restricting the amount and duration of data used for advertising purposes.
In its ruling on Friday, the court declared that the aggregation, analysis and processing of all personal data without any time limit or distinction between the different types of data goes against the principle of data minimisation.
In turn, Meta said it that it “takes privacy very seriously.”
Biden ‘not confident’ of peaceful US election
US President Joe Biden said Friday he was not confident the US election in November would be peaceful, citing incendiary comments by Republican contender Donald Trump, who still rejects his 2020 defeat.
Biden’s warning came with lawmakers and analysts voicing concern over increasingly bellicose campaign language ahead of the vote.
Trump – who survived an assassination bid in July and another apparent plot in September – alleged widespread fraud after his defeat to Biden in 2020, and pro-Trump rioters riled up by his false claims ransacked the Capitol.
“I’m confident it will be free and fair. I don’t know whether it will be peaceful,” Biden told reporters as he discussed the election.
“The things that Trump has said and the things that he said last time out when he didn’t like the outcome of the election were very dangerous.”
Khamenei says Iran’s allies ‘will not back down’ in war with Israel
Iran’s supreme leader vowed in a rare address on Friday that his allies around the region would keep fighting Israel, as he defended his country’s missile strike on its arch-foe.
Ayatollah Ali Khamenei’s address in Tehran was the first since Iran launched its second ever attack on Israel, and also the first since exchanges of fire pitting Hezbollah fighters against Israeli troops escalated into full-blown war in Lebanon.
Israel announced it was shifting its focus to securing its border with Lebanon, saying its objective is to allow 60,000 Israelis displaced by a year of cross-border rocket attacks launched by Hezbollah to return to their homes.
Israel’s attacks on Hezbollah strongholds around Lebanon have killed more than 1,000 people since September 23, according to the Lebanese health ministry, and forced a million more to flee their homes in a country already mired in economic crisis.
They have also killed a host of Hezbollah commanders, an Iranian general and, in their biggest blow to the group in decades, assassinated its leader, Hassan Nasrallah.
Speaking to a crowd of thousands in Farsi-speaking Iran, he said in Arabic: “The resistance in the region will not back down with these martyrdoms, and will win.” Khamenei praised Hezbollah, saying that it was providing “a vital service to the entire region and the entire Islamic world”.
Sky News quotes the Lebanese government saying more than 2,000 people have been killed across the country in nearly a year of fighting between Israel and Hezbollah.
‘Nasrallah temporarily buried’ – source
Times of Israel quotes a source close to Hezbollah saying Friday that the Lebanese slain chief Hassan Nasrallah has been temporarily buried in a secret location for fear Israel would target a large funeral.
“Hassan Nasrallah has been temporarily buried until the circumstances allow for a public funeral,” the source said after an Israeli strike killed the leader last week.
Nasrallah still does not have a successor a week after he was killed. His cousin Hashem Safieddine, a prominent Hezbollah figure touted as a possible successor, was reportedly the target of an Israeli airstrike late Thursday on south Beirut. There is still no word on his fate.
Advanced Iraqi Kamikaze missiles used for the first time
In a groundbreaking military operation, Iraqi resistance fighters have launched an unprecedented attack on Israel using advanced kamikaze missiles, marking a significant escalation in regional hostilities.
This bold move targeted key installations in southern Israel near the Egyptian border, showcasing the evolving capabilities of Iraqi military forces. The strike has sent shockwaves throughout the region, raising alarms over the potential for increased conflict.
As tensions escalate, this historic use of advanced missile technology signifies a new phase in the ongoing struggle between Iraqi fighters and Israeli forces, further complicating the already volatile geopolitical landscape.
UK increases aid support to Lebanon
The UK is providing a further “lifesaving” aid package to Lebanon as it urged its nationals to leave immediately amid the spiralling Middle East conflict.
The UK Government said it is responding to concerns over a lack of shelter and reduced access to clean water, hygiene and healthcare by providing an additional £10 million in aid.
It is also continuing efforts to help Britons leave Lebanon after chartering a “limited number” of additional flights and trying to increase capacity on commercial flights.
More than 150 British nationals and dependants left Beirut on the first government-chartered flight on Wednesday, with another plane touching down in Birmingham on Thursday, as concerns mount over how long the capital’s airport can remain open.
Around 700 troops and Foreign Office and Home Office staff, including Border Force officers, have been deployed to Cyprus in case an emergency evacuation is needed.
Foreign Office Minister Anneliese Dodds said: “The human cost of the conflict in Lebanon is clear for all to see. This additional funding from the UK will help to address the rapidly-deteriorating humanitarian situation, providing relief for people displaced by the continuing violence.
“This lifesaving aid is vital, but not a long-term solution. The only way to truly address the growing humanitarian crisis is an immediate ceasefire adhered to by both sides.
G7 leaders have renewed calls for a cessation of hostilities in the region, warning of a “dangerous cycle of attacks and retaliation” leading to “uncontrollable” escalation and bolstered their condemnation of Iran.
‘World order under threat as it has never been before’
“The international world order is under threat like we haven’t seen since the Cold War,” the heads of the UK and US foreign intelligence services have warned.
Sir Richard Moore and William Burns, the heads of MI6 and the CIA, also said the two countries stood together to resist an assertive Russia and Putin’s war of aggression in Ukraine.
In a first-ever joint article, Sir Richard Moore and William Burns wrote in the Financial Times that they had seen the war in Ukraine coming “and were able to warn the international community,” partly by declassifying secrets to help Kjiv.
They also said efforts were being made to “disrupt Russia’s reckless sabotage campaign” across Europe, to push for de-escalation in the war between Israel and Gaza, and to combat terrorism to thwart the resurgence of the Islamic State.
EU’s defence industry programme may be too thin – Auditors
The EU’s flagship €1.5 billion Defence Industry Programme, EDIP, doesn’t have enough budget to match its objectives, the European Court of Auditors said in an opinion published on Thursday.
The European Commission proposed the programme in March 2024 as a stopgap measure after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, ahead of a longer-term structural increase in the bloc’s defences.
Commission President Ursula von der Leyen has now appointed a Defence Commissioner, Lithuania’s Andrius Kubilius, as the EU seeks to build capacity to meet the Russian threat.
While regulatory plans are still under review by lawmakers, the bloc’s official auditors reckon it needs a more robust policy design.
“It is also necessary to find the right balance between the policy objectives, the proposed budget and the timeline,” said Marek Opioła, the EU auditor in charge of the opinion.
In a 41-page document, the EU’s Luxembourg-based financial watchdog warned that finances could end up spread thinly across a wide range of projects with no measurable impact, and recommended setting realistic targets by the end of 2027.
The EU auditors also called on the Commission to consider a long-term funding strategy to boost defence capabilities in its next seven-year spending programme, due to start in 2028.
EU greenlights tariffs for Chinese electric vehicles
The European Union voted on Friday to pave the way for tariffs of up to 35.3 per cent on electric vehicles imported from China, a move that might set the stage for a protracted trade war with the Asian giant.
The vote comes after a year-long anti-subsidy investigation by the European Commission, which proposed the tariffs to counter what it sees as unfair Chinese subsidies.
Countries like France, Italy, Greece, and Poland had indicated they would support the tariffs, while Germany, Slovakia and Hungary were opposed.
The European Commission, the bloc’s executive arm, will now decide whether the import duties come into force at the beginning of November. The Commission has said the tariffs could be lifted if China addresses the EU’s concerns.
FIFA defers decision on request to suspend Israel
World football”s governing body FIFA made no verdict either way Thursday on a Palestinian request to suspend Israel, instead launching committee investigations to inform an eventual decision.
At FIFA’s congress in Bangkok in May, the Palestinian Football Association (PFA) called for its Israeli counterpart to be suspended and for Israeli teams to be banned from FIFA events.
FIFA was initially set to hold an extraordinary session of its ruling council before July 20 to review the independent legal analysis and decide how to proceed.
However the deadline was pushed back to give legal experts more time to complete a report.
At the organisation’s headquarters in Zurich, the FIFA council adopted the recommendations and conclusions reached in the legal analysis.
It decided that its disciplinary committee would be mandated to investigate the alleged discrimination offence raised by the PFA.