Invest or die

Economic development and capital accumulation are closely interlinked. Capital formation is a key to achieving economic growth, reducing unemployment, ensuring economic stability, and raising the standard of living of people. On the other hand, economic growth offers the potential to stimulate capital formation.
The essence of capital formation is the accumulation of physical capital stock in an economy through investment on social and economic infrastructures. Any increase in the stock of physical capital can be generated by both gross private capital formation and gross public capital formation. Government investment in infrastructural projects ̶ education, public health services, power supply, transportation, construction of airports, roads, water supply, and sewerage enhances the productivity of private investment.
Several empirical studies have found a strong positive relationship between the ratio of capital formation and the rate of economic growth. For example, in one 2000 study the authors found that during the 1990s, the ratio of total Gross Domestic Capital Formation (GDCF) to Gross Domestic Product (GDP) in Asia, which had a higher average growth rate than the rest of the world, was 27%, while the corresponding ratios were 20% and 17% in Latin America and Sub-Saharan Africa respectively.
The results also reveal interesting facts about the relative contributions of the three sources of economic growth: capital, labour, and technical progress. They indicate that technical progress is by far the most important direct source of economic growth for industrialised countries, accounting for more than 50 percent of the growth in real aggregate output (more than 80 percent for the European countries), followed by capital (with the exception of the United States), with labour a distant third.
Moreover, capital and technical progress combined account directly for more than 95 percent of the economic growth of industrialised countries except the United States. In the United States, where labour grew much more rapidly than in the other countries during this period, capital formation and technical progress still account directly for approximately 75 percent of economic growth.
Three stages
The process of capital formation encompasses the following three interrelated stages:
(1) stimulating an increase in the volume of real savings in the economy;
(2) mobilisation of these savings using financial and credit services institutions; and
(3) investment of the savings.
In the savings stage, individual households, firms and government institutions set aside a part of their current income or the available resources for future consumption or future investment in capital goods ̶ the buildings, schools, and hospitals mentioned earlier. Savings not only protect households against adverse life events but they also provide a dynamic entrepreneurial economy. The ability and willingness to save in a country depends on the level of income, the size of the family, and the standard of living. Businesses do the same thing by setting aside some of their profits ether for investment or to build reserves for when things go wrong. Finally, the government does the same thing by running fiscal surpluses.
Eurozone investment has fallen behind its pre-pandemic trend because of the underperformance of capital-intensive industries, high interest rates, and policy uncertainty. Governments are now also starting to tighten their belts, leaving little room for a vigorous recovery in the near term. The economy recovered less quickly from the pandemic and eurozone industry is going through a much larger correction than in the US. With industry being particularly capital intensive, it is easy to see why investment needs at this point are relatively low.
Capacity utilisation in the eurozone has been steadily declining since the first quarter of 2022 and is currently at 78.9%, well below the historical average of 80.8%. Part of this decline can clearly be attributed to the energy crisis since the start of the Russian invasion of Ukraine. In Malta, capacity utilisation in the first quarter of 2024 was 75.6% – down from 84.1% in the fourth quarter of 2023. Also, expectations for the near term are not necessarily very strong. Businesses remain worried about the limited potential for the eurozone economy in the near future. This has put the brakes on investment in the eurozone.
Like in the US, interest rates matter. As a driver of investment, the financial picture is currently deemed very unattractive and are still considered to be a considerable barrier to investment right now, according to a European Commission survey. The same can be seen when looking at reasons for bank lending, according to the European Central Bank, which indicates that high interest rates are contributing negatively to borrowing decisions. While observers expect modest declines in interest rates on the short end of the curve, longer-term interest rates are expected to remain around current levels for the foreseeable future, which means that the effects of monetary easing remain rather limited.
Other costs are also rising, which would lead to stronger investment requirements regardless of limited expansion opportunities. Wages ̶ the largest cost for most businesses ̶ have started to rise and labour shortages are large in the eurozone. So, investing to replace labour with capital would be a logical consideration. On the other hand, profits have been very strong and this has limited the immediate need for businesses to invest during a time of high interest rates.
Government investment has been recovering somewhat but spending is set to get squeezed in eurozone economies as fiscal prudence returns. Because eurozone economies are supposed to adhere to budget rules, the opportunities to boost investment are more limited. With populists gaining ground in many countries, traditional government expenditure on health and welfare will be harder to cut, which means that government investment and incentives for business investment are at risk.

Looking at the situation in Malta, various governments have often treated capital investment as a residual ̶ what remains available after recurrent expenditure is provided for. In the last 25 years, government gross fixed capital formation has averaged 3.5% of GDP ̶ slightly higher than the 3.2% achieved in the EU. What is striking from the chart, however, is that investment has been very cyclical, compared to a steadier trend in the EU.
In contrast, private gross fixed capital formation has averaged around 17.3% compared to 18.1% in the EU. Both percentages had been declining for two decades but picked up in the last five years, though Malta’s percentage remains lower. No doubt, a contributing factor to the modest recovery in investment was provided by the EU Recovery and Resilience Fund, which has played an important role in funding private and public investment, particularly in certain countries. But it seems that Malta is being rather slow in using the grants of €328 million allocated to us. So far, the Commission has only disbursed €72.9 million because Malta still has to fulfil 61% of its milestones and targets.
On the low side
In any case, it is clear that the overall investment rate of 22% in both the EU and Malta is on the low side. Some member states are achieving 25%-27%. This is the kind of rate that we should aim for over an extended period of time if we want to develop a new kind of economy based on higher productivity and value added. Probably the first thing we should do, actually, is to stop confusing recurrent expenditure with capital investment.
For example, various government ministers have taken to calling all sorts of economic and social hand-outs and subsidies an “investment”, when they are nothing of the sort. The Government support to private schools to prevent a 24% increase in fees was also hailed as an “investment”, when it is merely an annual subsidy included in the national accounts category of recurrent expenditure ̶ much like the contribution to church schools entered under the budgetary Programmes & Initiatives. I am not denying that the subsidy was a good move, simply that it has none of the characteristics of investment, namely higher future production, productivity, and a permanent increase in GDP.
Recently, Prof Mario Monti delivered another weighty report on investment in the EU and warned that, unless the member states substantially upped the game, the bloc is destined to wither. It is not the first warning of its sort and his recommendations need to be taken on board urgently. Should they? Most definitely. Will they? I have my misgivings. No doubt, the member states will take their sweet time considering them, cherry-picking a couple of proposals, and ignoring most of the rest.
Photo: Pixabay