Joseph Muscat concerned over PN’s offshore petrol station due to environmental hazard risks

Says European natural gas pipeline network remains most credible alternative
Former Prime Minister and Labour leader Joseph Muscat has cast serious doubt on the feasibility and credibility of the Nationalist Party’s proposal to relocate the LNG gas tanker to Hurd’s Bank.
In a strongly worded Facebook post, Muscat said he was surprised that no NGO has yet voiced concern over this proposal.
I’m surprised that those who voice their concern over developments in ODZ zones haven’t yet spoken out regarding this environmental hazard.
He said that the idea of removing the tanker from M’xlokk was part of a plan that has always been there and may have its advantages but it can pose a massive environmental risk.
He said in the same way people were concerned over one tanker close to shore, this proposal is much more concerning as it can have unimaginable dire ecological consequences in a wider area of the sea.
However, the worst thing is the lack of basic thought and the costings of the PN tied to this project that are far from realistic.
Firstly, one cannot relocate a tanker to Hurd’s Bank just like that. The system from FSU to FRSU needs to change, including regasification.
To build an FRSU would require around €600 million. A similar onshore plant, not at sea, in Livorno cost €575 million in 2014. If leased for instance, it would cost around €110,000 per day, equivalent to €40 million annually.
Additional facilities would also be required, such as a Single Point Mooring system, estimated to cost another €40 million. The pipeline connecting Hurd’s Bank to Delimara would add a further €50 million.
This does not even include backup facilities currently available under the existing system, nor the risk that if something goes wrong with the supply, the power station would stop operating.
In total, the project would amount to around €690 million, excluding a further €8 million annually in operational costs.
In reality the proposal could realistically cost €450 million when, according to his calculations, relocating the tanker by itself would exceed that figure by around €240 million.
Muscat argued that the government’s long-standing plan to connect Malta permanently to the European natural gas network through a pipeline remains the more credible and sustainable solution. He noted that the project had already received recognition at European level as a Project of Common Interest.
Muscat also accused the Nationalist Party of previously attempting to obstruct the pipeline proposal, saying even the Malta Chamber had criticised the Opposition at the time.