Recycling done badly

Nationalist MP Alex Borg has recycled a proposal initially put forward by the Nationalist government 15 years ago.
The proposal, which suggests reducing VAT on restaurants, was already rejected in the past due to its lack of tangible benefits to consumers. In a recent article in The Times of Malta, Borg presented this old idea as if it were a fresh proposal, even though earlier studies had shown that such a reduction would not lead to significant price decreases for consumers. For example, when VAT was reduced by 5% in Portugal, restaurant prices only fell by 1%, with most of the savings going into the pockets of restaurant owners rather than benefiting customers.
Two reports, commissioned by the Nationalist government at the time, concluded that cutting VAT on restaurants would have little impact on the economy and would not benefit the tourism industry either. One report, published in the 2010 Budget, observed that the economic impact of such a reduction would be minimal, with the majority of savings not being passed on to consumers. It further warned that the financial repercussions for the government would remain high, and that investments in the tourism sector would be a more effective strategy for attracting higher-spending tourists, ultimately benefiting the economy.

A second report, produced by Minister Tonio Fenech in his 2010 Budget speech, echoed these findings. Fenech argued that the experience of other countries where VAT reductions had been implemented showed that the benefits to consumers were limited, and that such a policy would not significantly support the tourism industry. He concluded that the government should not pursue a measure that would have such limited benefits for both consumers and the economy, while also creating a need for new taxes to compensate for lost revenue.

Despite these findings, Borg has completely ignored the evidence and reintroduced the same proposal, seemingly with little regard for the failed experiences of other countries. This is a complete lack of original thought and policy substance, and reflects poorly on Borg’s credibility and political judgment, which is even worse when we consider his ongoing campaign to replace Bernard Grech as the leader of the Nationalist Party.
These political manoeuvres seem more about creating a facade of new ideas than about bringing real, well-thought-out policies to the table.