The battle continues

A couple of weeks ago I attended a Cabinet meeting that was open to the public, when the ministers were given an update on the social welfare net and then heard from a number of people and organisations active in the social sector in the country. It was a satisfying experience and it seems that all participants found it very useful and constructive.
The social welfare net in Malta keeps improving and has evolved to cater for the needs of modern society. That much was clear from the presentation given by Mr Mark Musù, the Permanent Secretary in the Ministry for the Family and Social Policy. Minister Michael Falzon reminded everybody that each one of the actors could make a difference to the lives of vulnerable people. The Prime Minister confirmed that the upcoming Budget would have a strong social element. The interventions by activists showed that the Government has key and willing partners in its provision of social services.

One chart which struck me was that relating to ‘Support to families with children’, which shows the number of beneficiaries entitled to support to have risen by 60% to 73,300 beneficiaries whereas the benefits paid out have grown by 67% to €66.8 million.

Recalling the proceedings a few days later, I thought about the vital link between democratic sustainability, security, and social rights and how this link can play a crucial role in the face of rising populism across Europe. The European Parliament elections last May signalled a solid shift to the far right across much of Europe ̶ undoubtedly at least partly rooted in widespread public concern about falling standards of living.
We have not had a similar experience in Malta. Nor have we had widespread protests by wide swathes of society who have despaired of the future. Some people sanguinely attribute this to apathy. It’s a false narrative. When people have no hope left, they rise up and make their anger felt. Even if people have been sorely tested by the recent high inflation, it is clear that they still believe that the system is generally responding to their needs.
My readers must have realised by now that I am often a loud critic of extreme liberal ideology; that I am all for the free market but not for an unfettered one; that I believe we can do more to address income and wealth inequalities. But that does not mean that the system is rotten. It is because I am impatient when the government does not recalibrate its work quickly enough to ensure that democracy and governance are not undermined by inadequate protection of social rights.
In Europe we have what is known as the Council of Europe’s European Social Charter, the origins of which date back to 1961. It is the aftermath of various social struggles over the post-war years, and thesocial policies and social rights enunciated in it are associated with a shift in the societal paradigm.

Together with other human rights, social rights are universal, indivisible and inter-related. This interdependence makes the enjoyment of some social rights a precondition for the exercise of other human rights. Such ‘gateway’ rights include those to health, housing, social protection and protection against poverty, as well as employment.
The full enjoyment of social rights during childhood and youth ̶ including to education, protection against physical and moral dangers, housing and elimination of the cycle of poverty ̶ is a precondition for the enjoyment of human rights in later life. The pitfalls deriving from deficits in social rights are even greater for girls and young women, whose disadvantages can be compounded and perpetuated throughout their lifetimes and across generations.
The European Social Charter is not to be confused with the European Union’s 2017 European Pillar of Social Rights. The latter does not confer rights that are legally binding under international law. In fact, though the provisions set out in chapter IV of the EU’s Charter of Fundamental Rights, clearly draw on Council of Europe standards, it remains unclear whether the EU Charter’s ‘solidarity’ provisions are enforceable rights or merely ‘principles’. In contrast, the Council of Europe’s Charter ̶ subsequently reinforced by a 1988 protocol with additional rights ̶ is governed by a treaty supervisory mechanism, based on national reports and also strengthened with a system of quasi-judicial collective complaints.

Just over a year ago, the European Social Charter was accorded a key place in the Reykjavik Declaration, which is effectively a roadmap for the Council of Europe in the coming years. In it, the leaders stated that ‘social justice is crucial for democratic stability and security’ and reaffirmed their ‘full commitment to the protection and implementation of social rights as guaranteed by the European Social Charter system’.
The growing profile isn’t limited to the Council of Europe context. The La Hulpe Declaration on the future of the European Pillar of Social Rights, adopted in April under the Belgian EU presidency, includes “a commitment to promote social rights, building on the European Social Charter in pursuit of a social Europe”.
So, now we are in the happy situation where both the Council of Europe and the EU are cooperating closely. This is the background to the new and bolder social vision announced by European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen for her second mandate. Elaborated in dialogue with civil society and citizens, the 2030 objective is to reduce the number of people at risk of poverty or social exclusion by 15 million ̶ ending poverty for everyone byr 2040.
Von der Leyen has promised to address the root causes of poverty, which we all know is deeply connected to (un)employment, gender, household size, social and ethnic background, and place of living. Translating this commitment into actionable policies ̶ of which the long-sought-after directive on minimum incomes should be the first port of call, following the successful directive on adequate minimum wages ̶ will be the task of the new Commission.
Decent work at adequate wages is crucial to reduce poverty. It is the core promise of the European social-market economy. But blindly promoting work is not enough: in-work poverty is an unfortunate reality. We need to ensure that everyone, in or out of the labour market, has sufficient resources to live a life in dignity, sharing European prosperity.
Whether the Commission President will live up to her promises is another question. The Left in Europe has often been critical of her and did not support her reappointment, calling her “the continuing of austerity politics, pampering the 1% and punishing the poor.” We will see, but good socialists will make sure to remind her if she flags.

It would be wrong to think that the battle against poverty and social exclusion is won. Lurking in the corridors and working behind the scenes are still people with a blink faith in ‘neoliberalism’ and in unfettered markets, trying to stifle the social and welfare state. The ‘small state’ mantra preached by Business brought about considerable harm to swaths of society. Growing inequality was one of the insidious consequences, threatening social peace.
The responsibility of those in positions of political authority is great. We should be attentive to the alarm bells set off by the rise in populism and the unhinged nurturing of anti-system sentiments. Fighting these new risks will only be successful if we include the voices of all those affected and concerned by poverty: low-income and precariously employed households, civil-society organisations, the social partners, and the academic world must all have their say.