The PN Metro Proposal – Technical Detail, Timeframes, and Cost Implications.

Tunnelling is from a civil engineering perspective a complex field that makes the profession, along with mining, one of the most dangerous. It represents various physical challenges and risks that need to be mitigated with prudent and detailed engineering solutions.
Malta is not new to tunnels, beneath the ground lies a complex network of tunnels at various depths, servicing different uses including water, sewage, power, stormwater, fuel, and more.
Along the years a number of Maltese architects have become specialists in this field and Perit Julian Borg, the candidate/technical expert who fronted the PN’s metro technical presentation, is not one of them.
Let’s make something clear at the outset, the timeframes proposed are not at all credible, and this by a wide margin. Even if one had to exclude mandatory permitting and procurement procedures, which you cannot, what is being proposed is almost physically impossible from a project implementation point of view.
The PN is proposing using two tunnel boring machines commonly referred to in the industry as TBMs. These are massive and impressive machines, incredibly expensive, and are usually used for long distance continuous tunnels in stable geological conditions. They are not recommended for projects that are undertaken in areas with varying geological formations, fractured rock, or in excavations that require sharp turns or that are not linear. In fact most metro projects never rely on TBMs alone but use a mix of equipment including road headers. Road headers are similar machines that use a powerful robotic arm that offers greater flexibility in mixed geological settings and that can excavate customizable shapes with much greater ease of maneuverability. The last major tunneling project in Malta is a 10km 5 meter wide tunnel between Pembroke and Ta Qali, and this was exclusively excavated by road headers.
What the PN is proposing is technically questionable as it is highly unlikely that a metro project, in Malta’s very busy underground setting and fragmented geological formations, can rely solely on TBMs.
Perit Julian Borg made considerable effort during the presentation to explain how the works will not impact residents, apart from normal construction site conditions, and this only at the station location. This is also very far from the truth. First of all tunnels require various support structures to render a project feasible from a health and safety and operational perspective. These include frequent ventilation shafts, escape routes, and excavated material evacuation channels. In addition to this, such excavations, even if at considerable depth below ground level, can create significantly strong vibrations in overlying houses, especially in areas with hard rock formations, that are so prominent in numerous areas that are within the project’s scope. It is blatantly obvious that the impacts across the entire line are being underestimated.
Also, the resulting excavation material from the project will be of epic proportions. The figures quoted by the PN are diplomatically speaking doubtful. Moreover, getting the excavation material out of the tunnel to a final disposal route is a massive logistical challenge. If what the PN is proposing had to materialise, i.e. that the material will be used in Birzebbugia for freeport expansion purposes, the villages surrounding the area would be littered by hundreds of trucks presumably loading barges for dumping in the adjacent coastal waters. These challenges also appear to have been grossly overlooked.
A key characteristic of Malta’s geology is that although it has specific rock formations, it does produce sharp changes in characteristics over even the shortest of distances. Fissures, water pockets, and a myriad of other reasonably unpredictable challenges, also from existing subterranean infrastructure, make such projects extremely complex. One cannot simply compare execution time frames with other metro systems abroad. Add to this one of the busiest archaeological settings, and you would realise that the time frames being proposed by the PN are either coming from someone that is trying to take us all for a ride, or that has no idea of what he’s saying.
Those who have been involved in large infrastructure projects know that what is being put forward by the PN is not credible, those who have been involved in the local tunneling, would not even comment out of respect for the profession.
A project of this scale, if not implemented to perfection, can literally bankrupt a country. So far, not only has the PN not given the required reassurances, but has raised countless alarms on the feasibility and implementability of what it is proposing.