The road ahead: challenges facing this administration

A growing divide in income and wealth has left many people behind.

The central and local governments are mainly in the business of buying services for their constituents, paying providers to tackle a broad spectrum of social needs: health, education, employment, and justice, among others. But these governments face significant barriers to reducing costs and delivering high-quality services.

Both types of government keep track of their spending but have few, if any, quality controls to monitor what they’re really buying. Those governments have limited knowledge of what services are actually being provided and of the quality of those services. Regular national audit reports flagging such shortcomings corroborate this point.

Rather than developing and implementing long-term solutions, the current administration overwhelmingly appears to focus on fixing short-term problems. The emphasis is placed on fixing preventable problems rather than preventing those problems in the first place. For instance, instead of funding obesity prevention efforts, we pay enormous sums to remediate diabetes. Why? Could it be because the people in power won’t be around when prevention efforts results occur?

Again, for more than two decades, research has shown that drug-involved offenders receiving drug treatment in the community go on to commit significantly fewer crimes than drug-involved offenders who are incarcerated. Yet, recent studies show that less than four percent of drug-involved offenders receive court-monitored treatment. The problem? Drug treatment is more expensive than criminal case processing, and the resources to expand simply aren’t there.

The government rarely funds programmes that have excellent average effects but occasional unintended consequences. While drug courts overall lead to less crime, it is inevitable that some drug-involved offenders treated in the community will commit crimes that incarceration would have prevented. While the overall effect is more public safety, the fear of the less-dangerous side effects, like an occasional preventable crime, almost always wins out.

The government budget is split into department budgets and, then again, into agency budgets. So if one agency or department has a winning idea that reduces overall costs to the government, that idea will only go forward if that agency is the one that keeps the savings. If those benefiting from savings from successful evidence-based programmes do not include the agency covering the bill, that agency or department is unlikely to pursue the idea.

Not only are those budgets rigidly separated, but knowledge and data are as well. Each department tends to be isolated from the rest of the government, particularly with respect to information sharing and knowledge transfer. For the government, data systems not only can’t communicate but are often prohibited from doing so. If a child is in special education and involved in the juvenile justice system and the child welfare system, most places don’t allow those agencies to share case information, much less encourage them to do so. Thus, the response is inefficient, and the conflicting solutions can make problems worse. The result of all of this is an inefficient system that, at best, can be made more efficient and, at worst, can do more harm than good.

Coupled with all that, this administration will sure have to face more than one daunting challenge in the coming years. What should the government do? And how should it go about achieving its goals?

A grand challenge is making sure that Malta is deeply engaged with the rest of the world in our economic and national security interests. In this sense, our country has remarkably achieved a lot, but there is still much more to be accomplished.

Fostering better and more visible social equity is another challenge. A growing divide in income and wealth has left many people behind based on their race, gender, or geographic location, and many groups are marginalised or excluded from the political process. Urges to address issues such as affordable housing, criminal justice, education, and access to technology are continually felt.

Photo: Ádám Pálvölgyi

The fiscal health of the government has also been reasonably high on the list in the past years. Could it be that the huge structural deficit this administration has been creating is unsustainable? Continuing on this path risks having future elected officials find they don’t have enough money to meet their campaign promises or to invest in future growth—with insidious effects on citizens’ trust in government.

Climate change is a problem this government is already trying to address and one that demands more vigorous action from the public sector. And how can we ignore that mundane, but vital, topic of water safety and sustainability, which demands that ways be found to raise the hundreds of thousands of euros needed to ensure water safety and sustainability across the country?

Technology topics make the list as well, as I wish for more government action to promote data security and personal privacy and prepare for the coming age of artificial intelligence. “Adversarial AI” is now being used to doctor videos, putting words into the mouths of people who didn’t say them. So public authorities are challenged to aid citizens in identifying misinformation and disinformation — to stem the continuing erosion of trust in what experts and the media report.

Reskilling workers as technology advances is a problem that will continue engaging our central government, local government, and public administration in general. Employers can’t afford to give, and employees can’t afford to take, six months or a year off to get retrained, so better ways of delivering the training must be developed.

Finally, the central and local governments risk facing near-term difficulties due to such factors as rising healthcare costs. The central administration continues to cut taxes without corresponding spending cuts, while many government departments and agencies have increased spending without corresponding revenue increases. Limiting the powers of local councils does not help, either.

Furthermore, our national balance sheets have a time bomb of unfunded pension liabilities that could easily crowd out public investments in such areas as education and infrastructure over the next decade.

Addressing the few shortcomings and challenges I have humbly identified above would greatly improve our nation’s prospects. Let’s hope we have the will to succeed.

Main photo: id23

5 1 vote
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted