The “white hat” hacking dilemma

A new policy to strengthen Malta’s ICT systems and give legal clarity to the ethical hacking industry.

In March next year, three university students and their lecturer will face criminal charges following their discovery of a security flaw in Malta’s largest student app, FreeHour. The students, Luke Bjorn Scerri, Michael Debono, and Giorgio Grigolo, are accused of computer misuse after finding and reporting a vulnerability in the app.

The trio, all from the University of Malta, initially contacted FreeHour via email, alerting them to the security issue and requesting a ‘bug bounty’, a common practice in ethical hacking where security researchers are rewarded for finding flaws. However, instead of a reward, they were arrested, strip-searched, and had their computer equipment seized. The investigation into the case began in October 2022.

In response to this controversial situation, the Maltese Cabinet has published a consultation document to develop a national policy regulating ethical hacking. Open for public consultation until 9th October 2024, the policy aims to provide a clear legal framework for ethical hackers, often referred to as security researchers.

Ethical hackers, also known as “white-hat” hackers, play a vital role in protecting systems by identifying vulnerabilities before malicious hackers can exploit them. The proposed policy calls for ICT system owners and managers to implement a Coordinated Vulnerability Disclosure Policy (CVDP). While most companies can adopt this framework voluntarily, critical infrastructure organisations will be legally required to comply under European directives.

The Critical Infrastructure Protection Directorate (CIPD) will maintain a register of these CVDPs, which will serve as a reference point for ethical hackers. This ensures that security research is conducted in a controlled, legal environment. The policy is also designed to formalise the work of ethical hackers, building public trust and encouraging cooperation between organisations and researchers.

The Malta Digital Innovation Authority (MDIA) and the CIPD are spearheading this initiative, which is part of Malta’s National Cybersecurity Strategy 2023–2026. It also aligns with EU cybersecurity directives, aiming to boost digital safety across the country.

This policy will not only strengthen Malta’s ICT systems but also give legal clarity to the ethical hacking industry. Security researchers will be protected and recognised for their contributions under this policy.

The Government has already implemented an interim policy that offers guidance on how vulnerability testing should be conducted by ethical researchers. It outlines the conditions under which such tests can be carried out and provides a framework for distinguishing between constructive and malicious activities.

In conclusion, this new policy is a significant step towards regulating ethical hacking in Malta. It sets clear rules for ethical hackers, fostering greater collaboration between the Government, organisations, and security researchers, with the ultimate goal of enhancing cybersecurity and protecting everyone involved.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted